"I Have a Feeling"

"I Have a Feeling"

October 30, 2026•7 min read

"I Have a Feeling":
Why I Stopped Arguing With Your Gut

By Alicia Divico, LMHC, CAP, ICADC

I want to start with a confession. When I was newer to private practice, and a client told me they "had a feeling" about something, I challenged it. Gently, clinically, with the best of intentions, but I challenged it. Are you sure that's not anxiety talking? Could you be reading into things? Is this a pattern of expecting the worst? I thought I was helping people separate fact from fear.

Over the years, I have learned to do the opposite. Now when someone says "I have a feeling," I lean in. Because what I have watched, again and again, is that people are very often right.

What I Kept Seeing

Two groups stand out. The first is people in relationships. A client will come in and say something feels off with their partner. They can't point to anything concrete. There is no smoking gun. Just a sense that something has shifted. And more often than not, weeks or months later, the thing that was off comes to light: an affair, an addiction relapse, a decision to leave that the partner had already made privately, a depression they were hiding.

The second group is parents. A parent will tell me they have a feeling something is going on with their kid. The school says everything is fine. The pediatrician says it's a phase. The teenager says "I'm fine" with a shrug. And the parent turns out to be spot on, whether it's a child being bullied, using substances, struggling with self-worth, or carrying something they haven't found words for yet.

After enough of these, I had to be honest with myself. My job is not to talk people out of what they know. It's to help them understand it.

Intuition Isn't Magic. It's Data You Haven't Put Into Words Yet

Intuition gets talked about in two unhelpful ways. One camp treats it as mystical and infallible: your gut is always right, never question it. The other camp dismisses it as "just a feeling," unscientific and unreliable. The research lands somewhere more interesting than either.

Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio proposed what he called the somatic marker hypothesis: the idea that the body registers patterns and signals "good" or "bad" before the thinking mind catches up. In a well-known set of experiments using a card game called the Iowa Gambling Task, participants began showing physical stress responses when reaching toward the risky decks well before they could consciously explain which decks were bad. Their bodies knew first. Researchers have debated the details of that work since, but the core observation, that we often register a pattern before we can articulate it, has held up well.

Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein, who spent years on opposite sides of the question of whether intuition can be trusted, eventually wrote a joint paper laying out when it can. Their conclusion was that intuition is reliable when two conditions are met: the environment has real, consistent patterns in it, and the person has had extensive exposure to that environment with a chance to learn from it.

Now think about who has that kind of exposure. You have spent years learning the rhythm of your partner: how they text, how they laugh, how they walk in the door, how long they look at you. A parent has spent a child's entire life reading their face, their tone, their appetite, their silence. That is an enormous, detailed dataset. When something changes, even slightly, your nervous system notices the deviation long before you can build a case for it in words.

There's supporting evidence from medicine, too. Research on serious infections in children has found that a parent's sense that "this illness is different" is a meaningful warning sign worth taking seriously, and parents' concerns about their child's development are considered a valid early screening signal. The people who know someone best are often the first to register that something has changed.

A quick note on the phrase "gut feeling": it isn't literally your digestive tract doing the reasoning. The gut-brain connection is real and fascinating, but intuition is better understood as whole-body pattern recognition. Your brain reads signals from your heart rate, your breathing, your muscle tension, and yes, your stomach, and those signals carry information.

Why So Many of Us Were Taught to Ignore It

If intuition is this useful, why do so many people override it? Part of the answer is that many of us were trained to. Plenty of people grew up hearing "you're overreacting," "you're being dramatic," or "you're imagining things." Women in particular are often socialized to prioritize being agreeable over being accurate, and to worry more about seeming "crazy" than about protecting themselves. And in relationships where there is deception, the person being deceived is frequently told, directly or indirectly, that the problem is their paranoia.

Over time, people learn to argue with their own perception. That isn't a personal flaw. It's a learned response to environments that punished them for noticing. Part of healing is unlearning that.

The Honest Part: When a Feeling Is Not Intuition

I'd be doing you a disservice if I told you every feeling is a prophecy. It isn't. Intuition is powerful, but it can be clouded, and my early-career caution wasn't entirely wrong. It was just aimed at the wrong target.

Anxiety can masquerade as intuition. So can trauma. If you have been betrayed before, your nervous system may be scanning for danger everywhere, including where there is none. Bias can masquerade as intuition, too: a "bad feeling" about a person that is really about their race, their body, or their difference from you is not insight. It's a learned association, and it deserves scrutiny, not trust.

Remember Kahneman and Klein's conditions. Intuition is most reliable where you have deep, direct experience. Your gut about your own child is working from years of data. Your gut about a stranger in a category you've been taught to fear is working from very little.

How to Tell the Difference

These are the questions I walk through with clients. None of them are foolproof, but together they help sort signal from noise.

Is it specific or global? Intuition tends to be about something particular: this person, this situation, this change. Anxiety tends to be broad and shape-shifting. When one worry resolves, another takes its place.

Is it new, or is it familiar? If you've felt this exact dread in every relationship you've ever had, it may be your history speaking. If it's new, and it showed up with this person or at this moment, pay closer attention.

What have you actually noticed? Slow down and name the observations underneath the feeling. "He stopped leaving his phone face-up." "She hasn't mentioned her friends in weeks." Often the feeling is a summary of a dozen small data points you already have.

Does it ask you to pay attention, or demand certainty right now? Intuition often feels quiet and steady, like a tap on the shoulder. Anxiety tends to feel urgent and loud, insisting that you know immediately and act immediately.

What happens when you get more information? A true intuitive signal usually gets clearer as you learn more. Anxiety often just moves the goalposts.

What I Do Now

These days, when someone tells me they have a feeling, I don't ask them to defend it. I ask them to describe it. When did you first notice it? What changed? Where do you feel it in your body? What would it mean if you were right? What would it mean if you were wrong?

That shift, from "prove it" to "tell me more," changes everything. It treats the feeling as information rather than a verdict. It lets the person be both curious and self-respecting. And very often, somewhere in that conversation, they realize they already know more than they were letting themselves admit.

Trust Your Gut, and Get Curious About It

So here is what I want you to take from this. When you have a feeling about someone you love, or about a situation you know well, don't rush to talk yourself out of it. You may be picking up on something real that your conscious mind hasn't caught up to yet.

Trusting your gut doesn't mean acting on every flicker of unease. It means taking it seriously enough to look closer. Ask the questions. Notice the details. Let the feeling lead you toward information instead of away from it.

You are allowed to know what you know. Sometimes the most healing thing you can do is stop arguing with yourself.

Alicia Divico, LMHC

Alicia Divico, LMHC

Alicia Divico, LMHC, is the founder of Personal Wellness Solutions in Tampa, Florida. With extensive experience in both mental health and addiction treatment, she provides compassionate, evidence-based care through virtual and in-person therapy. Alicia is passionate about helping individuals overcome trauma, codependency, and life’s challenges by offering personalized support tailored to each client’s unique needs.

Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog